SYDNEY, Aus --Susan Sotelo, who stabbed her baby daughter, Zoe, to
death, cut out the infant's heart and dumped her tiny corpse in a
garbage bin has been found not guilty by reason of insanity.
The judge accepted psychiatric evidence that our Heroine "did not
know that what she was doing was wrong" -- fully believing she
was Jesus Christ and that her family was "celestial".
On the day of the killing, Suzy had attempted to smother the baby with
a pillow but was interrupted by a visit from a friend. After the friend
left, Suzy "heard a voice" telling her she "had to
sacrifice Zoe", so she finished the job (and a bit more, eh?) with
a kitchen knife.
MILWAUKEE -- Elise Ledvina, who had stopped taking her anti-psych
medication, tonight stands accused of brutally beating her two sons
with a 33-in. baseball bat, snuffing one and critically maiming
the other.
8-year-old John was declared dead of multiple skull frac- tures at
Children's Hospital of Wisconsin. 9-year-old Joseph was in critical
condition at press time.
Police say the father, who was outside repairing a bicycle, heard a
strange, steady "thumping noise" eminating from the basement.
When he entered the house, he found our Heroine beating the bejesus out
of little Johnny Jr. with the bat, yelling her desire that the boys to
"go to heaven... because they will not be productive members of
society."
Cops say John Sr. grabbed his wife and tried at the same time to call
the police but she broke free, ran upstairs and proceeded to attacked
the second boy, who was in bed reading a bedtime story.
The father eventually disarmed his wife and held her down until cops
arrived. Elise was arrested at the scene Tuesday; charges -- most likely
first-degree intentional homicide and attempted first- degree intentional
homicide-- are expected later this week.
36-year-old Julia Ann Olivas and 43-year-old Esther Rebecca Griggs have
been convicted of the paddling death of a 5-year-old girl they believed
was possessed by the devil.
A Los Angeles Superior Court jury found our god-fearing Heroines guilty
today of first-degree murder and assault with a deadly weapon in
connection with little Breean Spickard's 1996 merciless beating death
in Baldwin Park.
The jury deadlocked on the special circumstance of intentional infliction
of torture against Olivas and found it not to be true in Griggs' case.
That charge would have made the gals eligible for the Magic Needle. Oh
darn.
On a brighter note, both broads are expected to face 26 years to life
in prison when they're sentenced on Nov. 12th.
Prosecutors say Olivas told Spickard's mother, 34-year-old Deborah
Elizabeth Reynolds, to beat her daughter because she was possessed by
Satan, and that Griggs provided the paddle used in the beating.
Deputy District Attorney Steven Slavitt said, "Griggs stuck her foot
in the girl's mouth to prevent her from crying during the beating... It was
the worst beating I have ever seen. They just left her there to die."
Reynolds pleaded guilty to second-degree murder last week and testified
against the other two women. She's expected to face a prison term of 15
years to life in state prison when a judge sentences her Nov. 7th.
Miami Herald, November 29, 1997 (Excerpt)
Pastor accused of raping girl from church
Daniel Garnicki is a controversial pastor accustomed to his share of
negative attention.
He has been sued, accused of brainwashing and even vandalism. But these
days the renegade storefront minister has a bigger fight on his hands: He is
charged with taking a 15-year-old girl to a Holiday Inn and forcing her to
have sex while a porn video rolled.
Garnicki, 35, is the evangelical leader of the Camino de Santidad -- or
Holy Way -- church on Calle Ocho and 18th Avenue. It is the kind of place
where pedestrians walking down the street are encouraged to attend the
nightly services. It is the kind of church where hundreds every day pack in
for services that go on for several hours.
Although he has been allowed to continue a four-hour Christian radio
program broadcast daily on 1080 AM, Garnicki is temporarily out of the
pulpit. House arrest confines him to his Sweetwater home.
"Right now we don't have any comment," said a relative at Garnicki's home
who identified himself as Carlos. "Just don't put anything in the paper
that's not true, because he's being charged with something that's not true."
His attorney, David Markus, said his client is innocent.
Garnicki was arrested in September when a high school student in Miami
Beach told her teacher she had been sexually assaulted. The teacher told a
counselor. The counselor told the cops.
"I felt she was credible, and this did occur," said Miami Beach detective
Marilyn Tepperberg. "She was very upset about it."
The girl's story was very detailed. And although weeks passed before she
came forward, her account was backed up by the evidence and witness
testimony, sources said.
The girl, now 16, told police and prosecutors that one night after the
7:30 p.m. service, Garnicki went with her to see her mother in the hospital.
She was worried about her mother's illness and Garnicki offered to pray with
her.
The two met at a Blockbuster video store on Miami Beach, where one of the
girl's teachers allegedly saw her and Garnicki.
Garnicki allegedly told the girl he needed her help with a study on the
difference between Christian women and worldly women and pornography. His
research was to take place at the Holiday Inn on Collins Avenue in Miami
Beach.
He allegedly ordered a pornographic movie called Raw Flesh from the
hotel's cable service. As it played, he asked the girl how she felt. As he
continued asking her, she said he started touching her.
She told police he forced her to perform oral sex and then had intercourse
with her. When it was over, he told her she had sinned and needed to pray.
When police interviewed him, Garnicki denied even going to the hotel. His
wife told police it was she who went to the Holiday Inn with her husband.
But sources said Garnicki will have to overcome some obstacles: he
registered under his own name; the cable company confirms the pay-per-view
was ordered; and the hotel clerk distinctly remembers the girl there with
him, and that he refused to pay for the video.
"She knew a lot of things she could not have known if she was not there,"
one law enforcement source said of the alleged victim.
Markus, Garnicki's attorney, said those are the state's version of events,
not necessarily the facts. He said Garnicki was at the hotel -- with his
wife.
"He adamantly denies what the girl says. His position is that the girl is
a liar," Markus said. "The girl has problems and the jury will hear about
them."
After Garnicki's arrest, he was placed under house arrest with orders to
stay away from children. Police tailed him and learned he was still preaching
every day -- in the company of families with children. Prosecutors went back
to court to have a judge order the minister away from his 1,000-member
church.
"The church backs him 100 percent," Markus said.
The church is a controversial one in the religious community. Garnicki,
whose services were often broadcast on cable television, was suspected by the
pastor of a nearby Catholic church of inciting followers to desecrate its
religious statues. And Garnicki was one of several pastors who recently urged
his membership to fight a county gay rights ordinance.
(Excerpted)....
DALLAS -- A South Dallas pastor awaiting trial on a charge of sexually
molesting a girl has been arrested again, this time in connection with
the attempted sexual assault of a 3-year-old girl.
The Rev. Ronroyal Owens was arrested Monday afternoon after a friend who
had invited Mr. Owens to her house reported that she found him nude and
in bed with her 3-year-old daughter.
Mr. Owens, arrested at his office at Pleasant Grove Missionary Baptist
Church, was charged with attempted aggravated sexual assault. He was in
the Lew Sterrett Justice Center late Tuesday in lieu of $300,000 bail and
could not be reached for comment.
Officials at Pleasant Grove Missionary Baptist Church did not return calls.
Mr. Owens' attorney, State Sen. Royce West, D-Dallas, said he would not
comment on the latest charge against his client.
"There is still a presumption in America that people are innocent
until proven guilty," Mr. West said. "People should not be too
quick to jump to conclusions... Let the legal system work and then make
a decision."
At the time of his Monday arrest, he was awaiting trial on an aggravated
sexual assault charge stemming from a March incident in which an
11-year-old girl reported that she was lured into the church rectory and
molested. Mr. Owens was arrested a week later and released two days after
that on a $35,000
Police said Tuesday that they had not determined the extent of the
3-year-old's injuries. Her mother, who is not being identified to protect
the identity of her daughter, called police to her Mountain Creek home
around 1:30 a.m. Monday. She told police she had just put her child to
bed and went to sleep in the living room of her home, along with Mr.
Owens, whom police described as a friend of hers. The woman said she woke
up alone several minutes later and went to her child's room, where she
found Mr. Owens nude and touching the girl's leg, officials said. The
woman reported that the child's panties had been pulled down and her
nightgown was raised.
(Attribution: Arizona Daily Star - Tucson, AZ Feb 24, 1998)
PIMA COUNTY, Az -- Minister William Roush gave one last fiery speech
yesterday before a judge sentenced him to 29 years in prison for
brutalizing his two stepsons.
"I ask for leniency because I did not do anything wrong," a
defiant Roush told Judge John Leonardo.
A jury convicted Roush of breaking his 13-year-old step-son's arm with
a *shovel*, threatening the boy with knives and beating his 10-year-old
stepson with a rake handle so hard it broke.
"Everything has been taken away by the injustice of this United
States court," Roush said as he argued that his wife concocted tales
of abuse to get revenge against him.
According to court records, Mr. Wonderful attacked the boysafter one of
them failed to rake the yard. After taking them into the garage, he locked
the door and pummeled 'em with a rake handle until it broke on the younger
boy.
About an hour later, Roush and the older boy were in the family's kitchen
when the minister kicked the teen in the stomach, grabbed a knife and put
the boy's head down on the counter with the knife to his neck.
9:34 PM 3/2/1998
Mom believed demon in baby, court is told
By ARMANDO VILLAFRANCA
Evonne Rodriguez's mother testified Monday her daughter believed her
infant son was possessed by demons when she killed him.
Victoria Rodriguez said her daughter told her on the phone Jan. 29, 1997,
that demons had entered her baby and she had tried to pull them out.
"Mama, I'm trying to get the demons out of the baby. Mama, I'm like
an instrument," the elder Rodriguez testified.
She said her daughter described a harrowing scene in her north Houston home
in which "she heard a lot of screaming, screeching voices, pounding on
the windows."
"Just awful, worse than hell, worse than Halloween, just like hell,
mom," she said her daughter told her.
Later that night, Evonne Rodriguez, then 20, was charged with capital murder
after confessing the day before to killing her 4-month-old son, Ramiro Isabel
Valdez Jr., by beating him with her hand and choking him with a rosary.
Rodriguez reported to police Jan. 28 her baby had been kidnapped from a
downtown mall restroom.
The next morning, she took suspicious investigators to Buffalo Bayou and
showed them how she threw the baby, whom she had wrapped in a plastic bag,
into the water. The infant's body was never found.
Mac Secrest, Rodriguez's attorney, is basing her defense on temporary
insanity, saying she had been distraught over a bad relationship with
her son's father.
The defendant's mother, who broke down several times, testified her
daughter had bouts of depression and low self-esteem.
The elder Rodriguez never said her daughter admitted the killing during
the phone conversation but she had asked her why she had concocted the
kidnapping story.
She said her daughter believed authorities would accept the story.
Later in their conversation, the mother said, her daughter said everything
was under control.
"She had a very strange tone, a very sickly tone in her voice,"
Victoria Rodriguez said.
From "The New Hampshire" Nov 25, 1997 (c) University of NH
NASHUA -Bishop Guertin High School in Nashua well re-examine its student
safety policies following the arrest of a teacher charged with illegally
teaching after an earlier sex conviction.
State law bans sex offenders from working with children.
Guertin officials knew of Brother Shawn McEnany's criminal record in Maine
when they offered him a teaching position at the school in 1990.
Brother Leo Labbe, Guertin's headmaster, has defended that decision, but
in a letter to parents he acknowledged that some parents and students at
the school have disagreed with the choice.
He said that in hindsight, he perhaps should have considered that
perspective.
-=-=-
(Gleaned elsewhere:)
A school spokesperson said that McEnany was not a risky hire because
in 1990, the school was for boys only, and McEnany's 1988 conviction
involved a girl.
-=-=-
And from "Education Week" January 1998:
Back For More?
A teacher in a Roman Catholic high school could face up to 15 years in
prison if found guilty of breaking a New Hampshire law that bars convicted
sexual offenders from working with children. The Hillsborough County
attorney's office says that Brother Shawn McEnany broke the state
prohibition by taking a job at the 800-student Bishop Guertin High School
in Nashua, two years after he pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor sexual-contact
charge involving a 15-year-old female parochial school student in Maine.
Following a local journalist's inquiry, Nashua police investigated the
matter and arrested Brother McEnany. A lawyer representing Brother McEnany
says the teacher did not believe that the New Hampshire law, which went
into effect after his Maine conviction, applied to a misdemeanor.
... Lord, save me from your followers!
* According to a September federal indictment in Des Moines, Iowa, Kenneth
Ray Bruner (who is the stepson of a Pentacostal minister in Oklahoma City)
led his seven accomplices in prayer three weeks earlier, asking for God's
protection just before they set out to knock off Hermans Fine Jewelry.
Bruner acknowledged, according to the indictment, "that they were
going to do bad things but that they were not bad people." No one
was hurt in the robbery, and everyone was behind bars by the following day.
Priest Gets Life For Sex Assaults
.c The Associated Press
DALLAS (AP) - A suspended priest convicted of molesting altar boys was
sentenced to life in prison less than a year after the scandal led to a
record $119.6 million verdict against the Catholic Diocese of Dallas.
Rudolph ``Rudy'' Kos, 52, was sentenced Wednesday for convictions on three
counts of aggravated sexual assault. He also was sentenced to 20-year prison
terms for convictions on four other counts. He had pleaded guilty to one
count of sexual assault of a child and two counts of indecency with a child.
Kos will be eligible to seek parole in 15 years.
``He's gotten what he deserved. It should be death, but he got the most
that the law allows,'' said Wade Schlosstein, one of those who accused Kos
of assault.
The charges arose from the claims of four former altar boys who told police
they were molested about 1,350 times over five years from the time they were
10, 11 or 12 years old.
Before the sentences were announced, some of Kos' accusers addressed him in
court.
``Because of you, I thought I wasn't even deserving of my own family. And I
asked you why, why you should do this to me?'' Robert Hultz said. ``I hope
you never forget my eyes and the pain you have caused.
``It is men like you that bedevil our society, and thank God you will no
longer be a part of it.''
As one of his accusers addressed him, Kos called out: ``You're a liar.''
Some victims and their families said they will fight his attempts for
parole.
``There's no more you can do to the man than put him away for life and I
hope he stays there,'' said Pat Lemberger, whose 21-year-old-son Jay killed
himself in 1992, allegedly after years of Kos' abuse. ``Fifteen years from
now, if he's eligible for parole, I will be at the parole board, I can tell
you that.''
Last year, another jury returned the multimillion-dollar verdict against the
Dallas diocese in lawsuits filed on behalf of 11 men who accused the diocese
of covering up for Kos' assaults at three area churches from 1981 to 1992. It
was the largest clergy sexual abuse award in U.S. history.
Last month, the diocese reached a $7.5 million settlement with three of the
11 plaintiffs in the civil case. Eight plaintiffs remain in mediation with
the diocese.
After the sentencing, the Diocese said in a statement: ``We hope with the
conclusion of the criminal cases that all of us can move forward with the
healing process.''
AP-NY-04-02-98 0316EST
Copyright 1998 The Associated Press. The information contained in the AP news
report may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or otherwise distributed
without the prior written authority of The Associated Press. All active
hyperlinks have been inserted by AOL.
Return to the Clergy Abuse Index page.
Section 11:
1 Herald Plaza,Miami,FL,33132
(Fax 305-527-8955 or 305-376-8950)
(E-Mail: HeraldEd@aol.com)
(http://www.herald.com)
By FRANCES ROBLES
Herald Staff Writer
Copyright 1998 Houston Chronicle
* Origin: From the Northwest Corner of Nowhere (1:123/67.5)
The views and opinions stated within this web page are those of the
author or authors which wrote them and may not reflect the views and
opinions of the ISP or account user which hosts the web page.
Return to The Skeptic Tank's main Index page.